Follow the Soapbox
 
Picture
So Much for America's Superior "Moral Worth"
Counter Punch
by ALEXANDER COCKBURN
05/12/2015

On Sunday, the London Review of Books published an new account of the killing of Osama Bin Laden by legendary investigative reporter Seymour Hersh, which exposed the story told by the Obama Administration to be, in Hersh’s piquant words, “a blatant lie.” Using sources inside the CIA and Pakistani intelligence, Hersh dismantles plank-by-plank the official narrative first paraded by President Obama in his public address a few hours after the raid in Abbottabad and later embellished by John Brennan.


In sum, Hersh’s revelations reveal that: At the time of the raid Bin Laden was essentially an invalid. He was living under a sort of house arrest by the Pakistanis, who were monitoring him 24/7. US intelligence was alerted to Bin Laden’s presence in Abbottabad  by “walk-in” informant, who wanted to collect (and, in fact, did) a portion of the $25 million award. Pakistani intelligence helped provide DNA evidence, collected by Bin Laden’s doctor who was also an ISI agent, confirming Bin Laden’s identity prior to the raid. The CIA alerted Pakistan to the timing of the raid. Pakistani intelligence turned off the electric power to Abbottabad , cleared the flight path for US helicopters and provided an on-the-ground agent to guide Navy SEALS through the house. There was no firefight in the Bin Laden compound. Navy SEALS were under orders to kill Bin Laden on site. Bin Laden offered no armed resistance. No significant intelligence was collected from the compound. As a result of this cooperation, dark money to Pakistani intelligence and the military once again began to flow and the US consented to allow Pakistani a freer hand inside Afghanistan as the US began its withdrawal.

Hersh’s report demolished one of the cornerstones of the myth constructed by the CIA about the killing of Bin Laden: that the use torture had led to the discovery of a network of couriers which they eventually tracked to the white house in Abbottabad. That lie has now been crushed.

Predictably Hersh has become under withering attack from torture apologists and Obama defenders, especially the talking heads on MS-DNC. Last night, MS-DNC’s hipster teleprompter reader Chris Hayes lead the attack on Hersh, while simultaneously cheerleading the findings of the MS-DNC “investigative” team which “independently confirmed” the two major assertions in Sy Hersh’s report. Hersh, to his credit, swatted down Hayes’s juvenile deprecations like the seasoned pro he is.

Hersh’s story confirms what Pakistanis have long considered common knowledge. In fact, soon after Bin Laden’s assassination we heard from a former Pakistani military officer, Shaukat Qadir, who told us the whole story “was bunk.”  According to Qadir: “For the record, this house has been under ISI surveillance while it was under construction. It was first raided in 2003, and the ISI just missed capturing al-Libi (he was later captured by the ISI close to Mardan in K-P Province). It has been raided on numerous occasions since.” Shaukat tells me that contrary to a report in the New York Times by Carlotta Gall on May 5, neither of the two trusted couriers were among the dead in the compound.”

Alexander Cockburn wrote a story about Qadir’s revelations and other glaring inconsistencies in the official account on May 6, 2011, four days after Bin Laden’s death. Here it is. — JSC 

Barack Obama, who pledged to restore ethical honor to the White House after the Bush years, is now burying himself under an active volcano of lies, mostly but not exclusively concerning the assassination of Osama bin Laden.

There was scarcely a sentence in the President’s Sunday night address, or in the subsequent briefing by John Brennan, his chief counter-terrorism coordinator, that has not been subsequently retracted by CIA director Leon Panetta or the White House press spokesman, Jay Carney, or by various documentary records.

The White House photograph of Obama, Clinton and top security advisors supposedly watching real-time footage of the Navy Seals’ onslaught on the Abbottabad compound, their killing of two men and a woman (excuse for the latter killing: the standard “caught in crossfire”) and liquidation of OBL himself turns out to have been a phony. BO and friends could have been watching basketball replays. Panetta has admitted the real-time video link stopped working before the Seals got into the compound.

Panetta also admits Osama bin Laden was not armed, and that he did not hide behind his young wife’s skirt. He conceded that under military rules of engagement Osama should have been taken prisoner, but then added vaguely that he showed some unspecified form of resistance. He probably reached for his walking stick, since he has been ailing from kidney and liver problems. As any black or brown resident in, say, the purview of the  Ramparts Division of the LAPD knows full well, reaching for a walking stick or even holding a cell phone can be a death warrant; multiply that likelihood by a factor of 100 if you are the world’s most wanted terrorist  in front of a score of heavily armed and homicidal Navy SEALs, no doubt amped up on amphetamine.

An admitted fan of the herb, Osama may have been stoned as part of his pain management program since there was a marijuana patch outside in the allotment and, like any world star in retirement, Osama liked to smoke a lot of weed and made DVDs of important speeches which stacked up forlornly on the bookshelf next to the bottles of pills and the Koran, hoping to get picked up by Al Jazeera or HBO. How his lieutenants must have yearned for his summary martyrdom as they received his importunate bulletins that they derail a train during Obama’s State of the Union and other madcap schemes.

The White House claims that issues of delicacy prohibit the release of photographs of Osama’s bullet-riddled face and required that after an alleged match with a relative’s DNA he be given a swift but formal sea burial in a weighted body bag dropped from the aircraft carrier Carl Vinson into the north Arabian Sea, presumably awaiting retrieval by salvagers with a fix on the Vinson’s position at the time of burial.

Maybe the Navy Seal photographer forgot to take his lens cap off. Obama’s claims of ethical sensitivity certainly ring hollow. He’s battling the wimp factor, and “Lo! The head of Osama” would be a nifty prop. There was lengthy display back in Bush-time of the mutilated bodies of Saddam’s sons Uday and Qusay, killed by US special forces in 2003, plus filming of Saddam’s own execution by hanging.

Further back, when DNA matches were unknown, US special forces verified Che Guevara’s execution by permitting many photographs immediately post-mortem. They also cut off Che’s hands, for subsequent verification by the CIA. We’re not talking Miss Manners here.

The official “back story” released Sunday night by Obama is that US intelligence learned of the Abbottabad compound only last August and spent the following months watching the place, following Osama’s trusted couriers and concluding that it was highly likely, though not certain, that Osama was there.

This is bunk. The three-storey house has been a well-known feature of Abbottabad. Shaukat Qadir, a well-connected Pakistan Army officer, reported to CounterPunch from Pakistan: “For the record, this house has been under ISI surveillance while it was under construction. It was first raided in 2003, and the ISI just missed capturing al-Libi (he was later captured by the ISI close to Mardan in K-P Province). It has been raided on numerous occasions since.”

Shaukat tells me that contrary to a report in the New York Times by Carlotta Gall on May 5, neither of the two trusted couriers were among the dead in the compound.

Shaukat: “The house where Osama had sought refuge belonged to two brothers from Mardan (a Pashtun dominated region of K-P) who had numerous aliases; locally they were known as Arshad (or Bara?meaning elder) and Chota (younger) Pathan, who have been residents of that house for seven years past. The rub is; neither one has been identified among the dead. If Osama was followed to this house by constant tracking of his courier who, according to CIA reports, shouldn’t one, if not both brothers, should have been present, shouldn’t they? But they weren’t. Of the seven bodies left behind (a female, a child and five men of ages ranging from mid-twenties to mid-thirties), none have been identified as being either brother?. “ Inference: “Osama was sold out. The operation was the result of entrapment. An entrapment organized through one or more of his most trusted aides?”

In fact, specific knowledge by US intelligence of the compound and its likely possible prime denizen goes back to 2005.

This has been established by Israel Shamir, also writing for CounterPunch. Shamir compares certain passages in the WikiLeaks documents on Guantanamo against those recently published by the New York Times and the Guardian.

Shamir reports these newspapers were working from the WikiLeaks files supplied to them (price unknown) by WikiLeaks’ former German employee, Daniel Domscheit-Berg, “who went AWOL after this appropriation”. Shamir says Domscheit-Berg made a deal with the Guardian which subsequently made a co-publication arrangement with the New York Times. “Both papers published the cables after redacting them, or should we say ‘censoring’ – removing everything the secret services demanded [they] remove.”

When Assange learned that the Guardian and the New York Times planned to publish the Guantanamo files, his WikiLeaks team also prepared the files and began to upload. So did the competitors, possessing the Domscheit-Berg appropriated copy.

The most important redactions by the Guardian and the New York Times, Shamir writes, “were  directly dictated by the US intelligence services. The name of Nashwan Abd Al Razzaq Abd Al Baqi, or by another name, Abdul Hadi al-Iraqi or by his number IZ-10026 was edited away from the file of Abu al-Libi (US9LY-010017DP) and elsewhere.”

This is significant because al-Iraqi was in close contact with al-Libi who had been designated by Osama in 2003 as his trusted, official courier, therefore aware of OBL’s whereabouts at all times. In the end, at separate times, the US captured both al-Libi and al-Iraqi, had them both tortured and thus became aware of al-Libi’s courier duties and hence the possibility that Osama was in Abbottabad.

Comparison of the redacted version of the Guardian and in the uncut version of WikiLeaks shows to what extent all the traces of al-Iraqi, the likely informer-under-torture, were removed at the behest of US intelligence. It was not connected to “caring about informers”, for al-Libi was understood at the time to have committed suicide in a Libyan jail just before the arrival of the US Ambassador in Tripoli. The file of al-Iraqi is missing in all databases; he was captured in 2005 and kept in various secret prisons, until transferred to Guantanamo where he remains detained.

So the trail to Abbottabad was known to the US intelligence services at least since 2005, when al-Libi was captured. “Careful reading of the file,” Shamir writes, “shows that al-Libi was connected with al-Iraqi since October 2002. In 2003, Osama stated al-Libi would be the official messenger between OBL and others in Pakistan. In mid-2003, al-Libi moved his family to Abbottabad, Pakistan and worked between Abbottabad and Peshawar. He maintained contact with al-Iraqi.”

We can conclude, from this narrative, that when the unredacted WikiLeaks files surfaced, US intelligence concluded that Osama’s associates would soon figure out that the Americans had made the appropriate connections and conjectures and there the associates urged him to move on with all due haste. So Obama decided to send in the Seals.

From this active volcano of lies, we can safely assume that Obama’s re-election campaign has been well and truly launched. Lift-off began on April 27 with the White House’s release of the long birth certificate. Obama seems to have problems with timely provision of convincing documentation about arrivals (his own) and departures (Bin Laden’s).

Release of the full birth certificate could have come in 2008, when it first became a minor issue. Instead Obama refused to authorize release until last week, by which time 25 per cent of all Americans and 50 per cent of all Republicans thought he was hiding something fishy. A photo of the dead Osama would have been useful this week in quelling speculation.

Had it not been for cloud cover over Abbottabad, the raid on Osama’s compound could have come on Friday, April 29, the same day as the royal wedding.

Saturday, April 30 was reserved for the attempted assassination of Colonel Gaddafi, with the dropping of precision-guided bombs on the house of his son Saif, who died along with three grandchildren. Saif, then four, was in the Gaddafi family compound on April 15, 1986 when bombs ordered up by Ronald Reagan were dropped from F-111s, killing his 15-month old sister, adopted by Gaddafi 11 months earlier.  Thus have Reagan and Obama shared a target. ‘Decapitation’ – going for the enemy’s top guy – is now standard Nato strategy. In the “shock and awe” assaults on Iraq in 2003, the prime mission of US bombers was to target whatever houses Saddam was presumed to be visiting. We can assume electronic eavesdrops or maybe a human observer told the Nato targeteers that Gaddafi himself was in the house that Saturday, and the bombers were swiftly dispatched from Nato’s Allied Air Command in Izmir, Turkey, whose overall commander is Lt-Gen Ralph J. Jodice II (US).

Would Obama have been briefed on the plan, or have signed off on a program of targeted assassination of Gaddafi? It seems a sure thing.

Reverse the rationale. If a Libyan bomber had blown up the wedding couple and a goodly tranche of the British upper crust in Westminster Abbey under justification that the whole place and its human contents, down to the grandchildren, not to mention the hats, were fair game because Cameron was there.

As the Oxford historian Mark Almond subsequently wrote in this site, “Little wonder, the royal newlyweds’ honeymoon was suddenly cancelled on Saturday. So much of William and Kate’s nuptials was choreographed around their parents’ and grandparents’ weddings that it was a fair guess that like Princess Elizabeth and Philip they were going to fly to Malta to start their honeymoon before going on to Kenya where three generations of Windsors have enjoyed cementing their relations. Malta is too close to Libya for comfort and Kenya’s Muslim minority might not be too friendly to a serving Nato officer.”

But Gaddafi survived. So Obama only had one bloodied feather in his cap when he gave one of the most morally repellent speeches I have ever heard delivered from the White House. Bush at least had the crude brio of a semi-literate jock when he vaunted America’s prowess. Obama’s “we nailed him” paragraphs of mendacity concluded with Dickensian Heepishness: “Tonight we are once again reminded that America can do whatever we set our mind to. That is the story of our history.”

Alas, the actual story of “our history” is an unrelenting ability to lie about everything, while simultaneously claiming America’s superior moral worth.

This article appeared in the May 6-8, 2011 edition of CounterPunch.

Alexander Cockburn’s Guillotined! and A Colossal Wreck are available from CounterPunch.



 


Comments

10/01/2015 8:28pm

Excellent post.Thanks for sharing this message.Really,Your blog is not only instructive but useful too.

Reply
10/14/2015 12:19am

This post is really astounding one! I was delighted to read this, very much useful. Many thanks

Reply
10/14/2015 9:54pm

I just want to thank to share your information and your website or blog, this is a simple and yet useful.

Reply
10/30/2015 6:38am

It's in reality a nice and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

Reply
11/30/2015 11:45pm

Excellent post.

Reply
12/01/2015 3:23am

it is really nice blog.

Reply

You have done a great job. Such a grate blog you post.

Reply

I read this article. Such a nice information share by you in this article.

Reply
12/15/2015 3:06am

Nice blog or also nice information share by you in this unique article.

Reply
12/15/2015 3:07am

Such a informative blog you share.

Reply
12/15/2015 3:08am

I like your blog or information which you give in the article.

Reply
12/15/2015 3:09am

Nice blog.Great information you shared with us.

Reply
12/15/2015 3:10am

You have explained it in a nice way. Thanks for sharing.

Reply

Your blog is really nice and unique.I like it so much. Looking forward to going over your web page again.

Reply

I really impressed after read this because of some quality work and informative thoughts.

Reply

I just wanna say thanks for the the article. Such a nice article.

Reply
12/15/2015 3:14am

I just subscribe your blog. This is a nice blog..

Reply

Thanks for your blog, It is informative for me.

Reply
B. Iteme
12/25/2015 11:30am

I couldn't care less what lies were told. I wish they would have flayed the cocksucker then rolled him in salt, wrapping him in bacon and feeding him to pigs. Fuck him and fuck you Cockbite.

Reply
01/28/2016 10:03pm

I read your blog.Really this blog keeping a unique and interesting information.Thanks for share with us.keep continuous.

Reply
01/28/2016 10:30pm

Really informative post share by you.Thanks for that kind different work.keep it.

Reply

Thanks greatly for one more worthwhile article I've been an enormous enthusiast to the previous few months and i really enjoy reading your posts

Reply
02/15/2016 12:09pm

HAPPY VALENTINE’S DAY HAPPY VALENTINE’S DAY AND HAPPY NEW YEAR 2016 HAPPY NEW YEAR 2016

Reply
04/11/2016 1:24am

http://www.rolandgarrosdirect.com

Reply
05/06/2016 3:33am

very good and nice site

Reply

get 100% result this very nice site

Reply

this is very best site i like your site

Reply

best solution nice

Reply

very healthful and strong site

Reply

I will surely read this completely and also will share to my blog! Informative much! Thanks for it!

Reply
05/28/2016 2:11am

Your site work is very good very nice

Reply
06/03/2016 4:36am

Many thanks for publishing this details. I simply wish to let you know that I merely look into your website as well as I discover it really appealing as well as interesting.

Reply
06/06/2016 11:06pm

your site very nice I am read this article

Reply
06/28/2016 4:39am

Wha! This is great full blog i like this type blog. Deferentially this blog have this quality big cost, special effects, thank for sharing this blog.

Reply

Vashikaran mantra comes in many form (of Veda right) for example Mantra is the power to control or someone some jobs and controls the power of evil; you will start once the Vashikaran mantra.

Reply
07/22/2016 5:27am

Wow, Great blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on...

Reply
08/16/2016 3:18am

Soon after WWI the exact German current economic climate was left over eroding given it suffered as a result of massive unsecured debt, created as a result of high challenge costs as a way to fight the exact war. Because years using WWI constant, Germany’s current economic climate steadily purchased worse. The swift rise in food bills were on the list of primary factors people connected with Weimar knowledgeable.

Reply
08/16/2016 3:19am

The expense of medical medical care insurance effects all people, those who’re starting their business or maybe marriage. There are variety of factors of which determine a lot of these cost, and your insurability, your wellbeing condition, picking a plan, in which you are, your age group, and sexual. Some software programs cost a reduced amount of, however, plus a number of people spend less with regard to their insurance, that’s for the reason that these unique factors are typically calculated into the expense of health insurance.

Reply
08/16/2016 3:19am

There are typically many approaches to add internet website marketing to your individual dental promotion plan. The web would be the actual gigantic market for a lot of company products. It is important to finish at minimum amount some internet website marketing for your dental corporation. Here are typically some tips for adding dental internet website marketing to your individual dental promotion plan.

Reply
08/16/2016 3:19am

Exclusive dog adopting offers attain greatly with popularity everywhere. A a digital pet is a electronic pet that you may have for your personel, and given it has formulated so well-liked, it happens to be obvious you don’t should really have some sort of actual furry friend, to absolutely love running some sort of pet.

Reply
08/16/2016 3:21am

This role on the SEO company is critical concerning promoting ones web small business. According to current day trends in internet promotion, it is significant to search for the right WEB OPTIMIZATION company intended for great effects. Some usual responsibilities on the SEO group include website design, formation of back-links, information composing, web page optimisation, directory site distribution, online video media development, mass media produces, blog site articles, selection regarding suitable key words, and extra.

Reply
08/26/2016 8:34am

thanks for sharing that..

Reply
08/26/2016 8:38am

mm, I just wanna say thanks for the the article. Such a nice article.

Reply
08/26/2016 8:40am

Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article

Reply

The article touching my heart.

Reply

Nice article with best content .

Reply

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you.

Reply
09/02/2016 5:30am

Good post. It is really help to us. Its give us lots of interest and pleasure. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. Its really a good article. It gives me lots of pleasure and interest!

Reply
09/03/2016 1:48am

It proved to be Very helpful to me. Thank you so much And I hope that other readers will also experience how I feel after reading your article

Reply
09/03/2016 3:47am

Great Post !! Very interesting topic will bookmark your site to check if you write more about in the future.

Reply
09/03/2016 4:58am

think this is one of the most important information for me. And i’m happy reading your article.

Reply

You have really shared a Informative and interesting blog post with people..

Reply

I am extremely impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your blog!

Reply
09/19/2016 10:57pm

I am extremely impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your blog!
Delighted so much to be here and also wanna say thanks a lot for providing this much pretty and interesting article. Good to be here and also wanna say thanks a lot for providing this interesting post.

Reply
09/25/2016 8:03am

asfvcx

Reply



Leave a Reply