Follow the Soapbox
 
Picture
WSWS.org
01/13/2015

“Free Speech” hypocrisy in the aftermath of the attack on Charlie Hebdo 9 January 2015 The attack on the editorial offices of Charlie Hebdo has shocked the public, which is horrified by the violent deaths of 12 people in the center of Paris. The video images, viewed by millions, of the gunmen firing their weapons and killing an already-wounded policeman have imparted to Wednesday’s events an extraordinary actuality.

In the immediate aftermath of the shootings, the state and media are seeking to exploit the fear and the confusion of the public. Once again, the political bankruptcy and essentially reactionary character of terrorism is exposed. It serves the interests of the state, which utilizes the opportunity provided by the terrorists to whip up support for authoritarianism and militarism. In 2003, when the Bush administration invaded Iraq, French popular opposition was so overwhelming that the government led by President Jacques Chirac was compelled to oppose the war, even in the face of massive political pressure from the United States. Now, 12 years later, as President François Hollande is striving to transform France into the United States’ principal ally in the “war on terror,” the attack in Paris plays into his hands.

In these efforts Hollande can rely on the media, which in such circumstances directs all its energies toward the emotional manipulation and political disorientation of the public. The capitalist media, skillfully combining the suppression of information with half-truths and outright lies, devises a narrative that is calculated to appeal not only to the basest instincts of the broad public, but also to its democratic and idealistic sentiments.

Throughout Europe and the United States, the claim is being made that the attack on the magazine Charlie Hebdo was an assault on the freedom of the press and the unalienable right of journalists in a democratic society to express themselves without loss of freedom or fear for their lives. The killing of the Charlie Hebdo cartoonists and editors is being proclaimed an assault on the principles of free speech that are, supposedly, held so dear in Europe and the United States. The attack on Charlie Hebdo is, thus, presented as another outrage by Muslims who cannot tolerate Western “freedoms.” From this the conclusion must be drawn that the “war on terror”—i.e., the imperialist onslaught on the Middle East, Central Asia and North and Central Africa—is an unavoidable necessity.

In the midst of this orgy of democratic hypocrisy, no reference is made to the fact that the American military, in the course of its wars in the Middle East, is responsible for the deaths of at least 15 journalists. In the on-going narrative of “Freedom of Speech Under Attack,” there is no place for any mention of the 2003 air-to-surface missile attack on the offices of Al Jazeera in Baghdad that left three journalists dead and four wounded.

Nor is anything being written or said about the July 2007 murder of two Reuters journalists working in Baghdad, staff photographer Namir Noor-Eldeen and driver Saeed Chmagh. Both men were deliberately targeted by US Apache gunships while on assignment in East Baghdad.

The American and international public was first able to view a video of the cold-blooded murder of the two journalists as well as a group of Iraqis—taken from one of the gunships—as the result of WikiLeaks’ release of classified material that it had obtained from an American soldier, Corporal Bradley Chelsea Manning.

And how has the United States and Europe acted to protect WikiLeaks’ exercise of free speech? Julian Assange, the founder and publisher of WikiLeaks, has been subjected to relentless persecution. Leading political and media figures in the United States and Canada have denounced him as a “terrorist” and demanded his arrest, with some even calling publicly for his murder. Assange is being pursued on fraudulent “rape” allegations concocted by American and Swedish intelligence services. He has been compelled to seek sanctuary in the Ecuadorian Embassy in London, which is under constant guard by British police who will seize Assange if he steps out of the embassy. As for Chelsea Manning, she is presently in prison, serving out a 35-year sentence for treason.

That is how the great capitalist “democracies” of North America and Europe have demonstrated their commitment to free speech and the safety of journalists!

The dishonest and hypocritical narrative spun out by the state and the media requires that Charlie Hebdo and its murdered cartoonists and journalists be upheld as martyrs to free speech and representatives of a revered democratic tradition of hard-hitting iconoclastic journalism.

In a column published Wednesday in the Financial Times, the liberal historian Simon Schama places Charlie Hebdo in a glorious tradition of journalistic irreverence that “is the lifeblood of freedom.” He recalls the great European satirists between the sixteenth and nineteenth centuries who subjected the great and powerful to their withering scorn. Among their illustrious targets, Schama reminds us, were the brutal Duke of Alba, who in the 1500s drowned the Dutch struggle for freedom in blood; the French “Sun King,” Louis XIV; the British Prime Minister William Pitt; and the Prince of Wales. “Satire,” writes Schama, “became the oxygen of politics, ventilating healthy howls of derision in coffee houses and taverns where caricatures circulated every day and every week.”

Schama places Charlie Hebdo in a tradition to which it does not belong. All the great satirists to whom Schama refers were representatives of a democratic Enlightenment who directed their scorn against the powerful and corrupt defenders of aristocratic privilege. In its relentlessly degrading portrayals of Muslims, Charlie Hebdo has mocked the poor and the powerless.

To speak bluntly and honestly about the sordid, cynical and degraded character of Charlie Hebdo is not to condone the killing of its personnel. But when the slogan “I am Charlie” is adopted and heavily promoted by the media as the slogan of protest demonstrations, those who have not been overwhelmed by state and media propaganda are obligated to reply: “We oppose the violent assault on the magazine, but we are not—and have nothing in common with—‘Charlie.’”

Marxists are no strangers to the struggle to overcome the influence of religion among the masses. But they conduct this struggle with the understanding that religious faith is sustained by conditions of adversity and desperate hardship. Religion is not to be mocked, but understood and criticized as Karl Marx understood and criticized it:

Religious distress is … the expression of real distress and also the protest against real distress. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, just as it is the spirit of spiritless conditions. It is the opium of the people.

“To abolish religion as the illusory happiness of the people is to demand their real happiness. The demand to give up illusions about the existing affairs is the demand to give up a state of affairs that needs illusions. The criticism of religion is therefore in embryo the criticism of the vale of tears, the halo of which is religion.” [Contribution to Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Law, in Marx and Engels Collected Works, Volume 3 (New York, 1975), pp. 175-76]

One has only to read these words to see the intellectual and moral chasm that separates Marxism from the unhealthy milieu of the ex-left political cynicism that has found expression in Charlie Hebdo. There has been nothing enlightening, let alone edifying, in their puerile and often obscene denigration of the Muslim religion and its traditions.

The cynically provocative anti-Muslim caricatures that have appeared on so many covers of Charlie Hebdo have pandered to and facilitated the growth of right-wing chauvinist movements in France. It is absurd to claim, by way of defense of Charlie Hebdo, that its cartoons are all “in good fun” and have no political consequences. Aside from the fact that the French government is desperate to rally support for its growing military agenda in Africa and the Middle East, France is a country where the influence of the neo-fascist National Front is growing rapidly. In this political context, Charlie Hebdo has facilitated the growth of a form of politicized anti-Muslim sentiment that bears a disturbing resemblance to the politicized anti-Semitism that emerged as a mass movement in France in the 1890s.

In its use of crude and vulgar caricatures that purvey a sinister and stereotyped image of Muslims, Charlie Hebdo recalls the cheap racist publications that played a significant role in fostering the anti-Semitic agitation that swept France during the famous Dreyfus Affair, which erupted in 1894 after a Jewish officer was accused and falsely convicted of espionage on behalf of Germany. In whipping up popular hatred of Jews, La Libre Parole [“Free Speech”], published by the infamous Edoard Adolfe Drumont, made highly effective use of cartoons that employed the familiar anti-Semitic devices. The caricatures served to inflame public opinion, inciting mobs against Dreyfus and his defenders, such as Emile Zola, the great novelist and author of J’Accuse.

The World Socialist Web Site, on the basis of long-standing political principles, opposes and unequivocally condemns the terrorist assault on Charlie Hebdo. But we refuse to join in the portrayal of Charlie Hebdo as a martyr to the cause of democracy and free speech, and we warn our readers to be wary of the reactionary agenda that motivates this hypocritical and dishonest campaign.

David North



 


Comments

Outstanding report. Really fascinating to read through. I really love to read these kinds of a pleasant post. Many thanks! keep rocking.

Reply
03/31/2015 11:11pm

I truly favor to reading your post. Thank you a lot for taking the time for you to share such a nice info.

Reply
04/01/2015 1:53am

I appreciate your blog its a interesting and it attract other peoples to read this blog..!!

Reply
04/08/2015 10:13pm

Excellent post.I want to thank you for this informative read, I really appreciate sharing this great post. Keep up your work.

Reply

Nice Information share. I like it.

Reply
04/10/2015 10:03pm

I will visit your blog regularly for some latest post. I will visit your blog regularly for Some latest post.

Reply
04/29/2015 10:28pm

I Like that kind a nice article. keep's continuous your writing.

Reply
04/29/2015 10:32pm

I Like that kind a nice Blog. keep's continuous your writing.

Reply
04/30/2015 12:46am

Thanks for making your short post and informative, I am not much of a reader but I really appreciate.

Reply

I hope the quality of your blog is maintained, because with this blog I got a lot of inspiration that is cool..!!

Reply
05/19/2015 10:32pm

This is very much great and hope fully nice blog.

Reply
05/19/2015 11:17pm

Your blog is really an inspiration to many. I'll be looking forward for more of your posts. Keep it up!

Reply
05/19/2015 11:36pm

Thank you very much for posting and sharing this great Blog..

Reply

Great post, just what i was looking for and i am looking forward to reading your other posts soon!

Reply

Great Post !! your post is very effective and useful...

Reply

I really had a great time with your post! I am looking forward to read more blog post regarding this!

Reply
10/26/2015 2:47am

Nice article, thanks for the information. It's very complete information. I will bookmark for next reference.

Reply
10/26/2015 2:48am

A very nice service. I am interested to come

Reply

This post is really astounding one! I was delighted to read this, very much useful. Many thanks

Reply
12/15/2015 11:45pm

Nice Post !! I like Your well written and useful information.

Reply
12/15/2015 11:46pm

Many people like your blogs. continuous it..

Reply
12/28/2015 8:49am

Keep publishing the nice carry out, Excellent to determine your internet site. I need to in order to thank you just for this great study!!

Reply
01/10/2016 11:14pm

Nice article. Think so new form of features have included in your article. Waiting for your next article.

Reply

Interesting article share and this blog is impresses more people to reading that blog.

Reply
01/14/2016 12:48am

Your point of view is the best among many. keep posting ..

Reply
01/15/2016 11:43pm

Thanks for share that type blog. Many people like that blogs....

Reply
01/15/2016 11:44pm

Nice Blog share. I like your post....

Reply
01/15/2016 11:45pm

Great post!! Really you share a impressive blog with us...

Reply
02/06/2016 3:43am

lovely post share.

Reply
03/01/2016 3:47am

This is the type of information that should be given and not the random misinformation that is at the other blogs.

Reply
03/05/2016 3:58am

I hope next time will much better. Inside If you on my homepage can be found more related content.

Reply

I like your all post. thanks for share that post.

Reply

Great blog share. I like your all type blogs.

Reply

Nice Post !! I like Your well written and useful information..

Reply

Many people like your blogs. continuous it....

Reply
06/08/2016 1:17pm

I hope next time will much better. Inside If you on my homepage can be found more related content.

Reply
06/08/2016 1:18pm

I like your all post. thanks for share that post

Reply
09/11/2016 1:04pm

Great blog share. I like your all type blogs.Many people like your blogs.

Reply
09/11/2016 1:05pm

I hope next time will much better. Inside If you on my homepage can be found more related content.

Reply
09/11/2016 1:06pm

I like your all post. thanks for share that post.

Reply
09/11/2016 1:07pm

http://skrotpriser.com
http://skrotpriser.com/skrotbiler.html
http://skrotpriser.com/kontakt.html

Reply



Leave a Reply