Follow the Soapbox
 
Picture
SPN
By Missy Comley Beattie
12/14/2014

I could not read the names without weeping—a list of
the tortured detainees. I stared at each name, lingering,
imagining, feeling. I thought of the euphemism, enhanced
interrogation, like collateral damage, a manipulation of words to mitigate the depravity by making the unacceptable sound less repugnant.

Torture by any other name is still torture.

Defending the CIA’s violations, former CIA Director Michael Hayden said this really wasn’t legally torture, but “we knew as bad as these people were, we were doing this to fellow human beings.” Really? Did they, the supporters of state sponsored horror, consider, even for a second, that the detainees were human beings?

Barack Obama said that post-9/11 torture is contrary to who we are. He’s wrong. It is exactly who we are.

Dick Cheney said the torture was “absolutely, totally justified,” dismissing allegations that the CIA withheld information from the White House. The torture program was Bush and Cheney’s new toy, and they were spectators to pain.

Bush defended the CIA: “They are good people. These are patriots.”

“It's incumbent upon a democracy in terms of our values that we represent to the world that when we have bad moments, we hold ourselves accountable,” said Sen. Claire McCaskill. This was not a mere “bad moment”, a minor misjudgment. It was calculated, designed, and approved by top officials.

Sen. Diane Feinstein said she hoped the public would view the report in the "spirit of a just society [that] functions under law, and that when we make mistakes we admit them, we correct them, and we move on." Feinstein continued: "I think that's an important thing."

Does Feinstein really believe our society is “just” and “functions under law”? How could she? But therein lies the huge obstacle towards justice. Her saying that admitting mistakes allows us to “move on” is the babble of someone who’s read the jacket of a self-help book, unless “correct them” means holding them responsible in a court of law—exactly what she opposes, since too many of her cronies are complicit.

The Bush/Cheney administration’s chamber of horrors is an extension of the greed, opportunism, and violence that pervade our system. Yielding nothing in terms of intelligence and security and, in fact, counterproductive, it was sport for officials at the top of that particular food chain. Even if it had provided information, it still would be wrong, illegal, morally reprehensible.

Bruce Jessen and Jim Mitchell, the two psychologists who formed a business and developed the theories of interrogation based on “learned helplessness,” are former military officers. They were paid $80 million for their vision. Arrest them.

Arrest them all. Hold criminally accountable the Bush/Cheney administration, the people who sanctioned torture, the participants, and those who stood by with silent approval.

Further, when anyone argues that the release of the report hurts American interests or America’s reputation, we must conclude that fear and denial have descended. Even though the hideous torture techniques were no secret. For instance, Lindsay Graham, easily aroused by war rhetoric, said, “Don’t release it now because the world is on fire.” I thought he liked the flames, conflagrations ignited and fanned by the USA. Graham’s concern must be the possibility of repercussions, a stained legacy.

While ignoring abuses within our own borders, the US accuses other countries of human rights violations using these as a pretext for invasion or regime change. We pretend to spread democracy without nurturing it at home. Exceptional doesn’t describe us. Those who believe in American exceptionalism are the men and women in positions of influence who wear a flag pin and the flag-waving, my-country-never-wrong nationalists who scream “USA! USA! USA!” in a crass display of arrogance. As fascism kudzu vines our lives.

Torture defines us. Torture is a Kill List. Torture is a drone.

Torture is war. Torture is incinerating men, women, and children to obtain coveted resources. Torture is turning other countries into wastelands with weapons that remain in the water, the soil, air, the DNA.

Torture is sending our young to die for lies, a uniform embellished with ribbons and metal medals, a Purple Heart, broken hearts, burial in a national cemetery. Torture is the loved one who returns from war a double or quadruple amputee, with PTSD, with a traumatic brain injury.

Torture is so far away we don’t know the dead, the maimed, their names. But torture is also nearby, where we do: Trayvon Martin, Eric Garner, Tamir Rice, John Crawford III, Darrien Hunt, Michael Brown, so many more. Torture is the growing number of homeless children, hungry children.

Torture is a militarized police force, organized to enervate, to mute us, to render us voiceless when conscienceless minds conceive and perpetrate egregious acts that are committed in our names.

Torture is exactly who we are—unless we prove otherwise.

We can’t just demand justice though. We also must follow it to completion, prosecute the criminals, end war, close our military bases. This includes the wars in our own neighborhoods, towns, and cities, anything that separates us from our humanity.

Bio: Missy Beattie has written for National Public Radio and Nashville Life Magazine. She was an instructor of memoirs writing at Johns Hopkins’ Osher Lifelong Learning Institute in Baltimore. Email: missybeat@gmail.com

 


Comments

Jeanne Brantingham
12/14/2014 1:09pm

Very well said...you've expressed exactly how I feel about this disgusting chapter in US history. If I believed in hell, I would hope everyone involved would forever burn in it.

Reply
08/05/2015 5:09am

truly written

Reply
09/09/2015 6:29am

I feel about this disgusting chapter in US history. If I believed in hell, I would hope everyone involved would forever burn in it.

Reply
09/20/2015 6:38am

the best escort service in delhi ncr

Reply
10/03/2015 1:17am

Very efficiently written information. It will be valuable to everyone who uses it, including myself. Thanks a lot!

Reply
12/15/2015 8:04am

As stated multiple times in multiple places, this is coming as soon as I get a few other issues fixed. It's near the very top of the to-do list.

Reply
12/15/2015 8:05am

Sorry, but I don't understand what you are saying.

Reply
12/15/2015 8:07am

No, this is all from scratch.

Reply

I am agree with you

Reply

It is really a informative article.

Reply
12/15/2015 8:27am

Contact us for Russian Escorts in Delhi.

Reply

great, now my Canon 40D work with Asus Transformer, but settings button don´t work, I hope that it will be fixed, continous shooting don´t work too, waiting fot time lapse too. THX

Reply

Very efficiently written information. It will be valuable to everyone who uses it, including myself. Thanks a lot!

Reply
01/28/2016 11:03pm

Great website, i like if you need call girls in Dwarka then visit us

Reply
01/28/2016 11:31pm

Searching for Top Call Girls in Dwarka, We have top Class escorts in Dwarka, for fun in the Night, Our High Class Call Girls in Gurgaon are top escorts in Industry and they have great qualities to gave you real fun time.

Reply
01/28/2016 11:32pm

We offer Delhi NCR Gurgaon hiprofile Call Girls for those are looking for high profile hotels Call Girls in Delhi city and Gurgaon. Our website gallery page contains most attractive female Call girls service providers in India.

VIP Call girls in Dwarka, Young Call Girls in Gurgaon
Our VIP Young Dwarka Call Girls are best in all aspects and will give u immense pleasure and satisfaction

Reply
01/28/2016 11:41pm

Great VIP Call girls in Dwarka, Young Call Girls in Gurgaon
Our VIP Young Dwarka Call Girls are best in all aspects and will give u immense pleasure and satisfaction

Reply
06/04/2016 5:02am

VIP young ladies, style models and high-class colleagues for you. Chandigarh Independent Girls service, Independent service in Chandigarh city. Find here most beautiful girls and models.

Reply
06/04/2016 10:15am

Escort service Available In Mahipalpur we Have High Class Call Girls In Mahipalpur

Reply
06/04/2016 10:17am

VIP Call Girls In Mahipalpur We high Class Russian Indian Models Available In Mahipalpur

Reply

High Class Independent Escort service available In Mahipalpur

Reply

You Are Searching For Top Class Escort Service In Mahipalpur ?

Reply
06/04/2016 10:22am

High Class Call Girls In Saket You Want Fun So Call Me-9599396846

Reply
06/04/2016 10:24am

You Are Looking For Escort Service In Saket ?

Reply
06/04/2016 10:36am

Hello Guys Ready For Fun We Have High Class Independent Indian Models Available In Saket

Reply
06/04/2016 11:14am

Russian Escort Service In Saket You Want Enjoy With Russian So Call Me-9599396846

Reply
06/25/2016 4:09am

Nice and effective blog post. The content is too short but effective. I love the information you share here. Its an well written blog post by you. This is awesome blog post.

Reply

I like that a awesome blog and say thanks for that amazing blog.

Reply
06/26/2016 10:13pm

Thanks for sharing useful information for us.I really enjoyed reading your blog, you have lots of great content

Reply
06/27/2016 12:03am

Wish you best of luck for all your best efforts.

Reply
06/27/2016 2:36am

Good post….. I have been searching this kind of post… thank you

Reply
06/27/2016 3:14am

I loved what you've done here. The design is elegant, your content classy. Appreciate this post. I'm interested in your article..!!

Reply
06/27/2016 4:05am

Good post. It is really help to us. Its give us lots of interest and pleasure. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. Its really a good article. It gives me lots of pleasure and interest..!!

Reply

I’m glad that you shared this helpful information with us.

Reply
06/28/2016 12:54am

Nice blog... Please keep us informed like this…

Reply

Thank you for the introduction of a range of information that is very interesting to see in this article..

Reply

Awesome and interesting article. Great things you've always shared with us.

Reply
06/28/2016 4:38am

So happy to read your post about that..

Reply

Excellent post share with us and this blog is impresses more people to reading that blog.!@

Reply

This post is really astounding one! I was delighted to read this, very much useful. Many thanks..!@

Reply
06/29/2016 3:07am

I read your all blog and so excited to learn more…

Reply

I like the way you have described the entire article. Along with i also like your site structure neat and clean. Thanks for sharing this awesome information with us.

Reply
06/29/2016 4:38am

Its really a good article. It gives me lots of pleasure and interest..!!

Reply
06/29/2016 5:48am

Great blog with fantastic advice

Reply

This website is good and always shares new thought….

Reply

It proved to be Very helpful to me. Thank you so much And I hope that other readers will also experience how I feel after reading your article

Reply
06/30/2016 10:23pm

Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful information specially the ultimate phase

Reply
07/01/2016 3:10am

I will surely read this completely and also will share to my blog! Informative much! Thanks for it!

Reply

Good post !! I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand.

Reply

Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post

Reply
07/02/2016 12:44am

Thank you for spreading our knowledge to us…

Reply
07/02/2016 5:10am

Many thanks for including my blog on your list. You are definitely one of my favorites! If you or your other followers are interested..

Reply
07/02/2016 6:17am

Thank you! It was a wonderful chance to visit this kind of site. I hope you will publish more on this topic. Thanks a lot for sharing with us!

Reply
07/06/2016 11:51am

Nice post . Thanks for sharing!

Reply
07/06/2016 11:55am

Nice Post ! If needed Escort website visit http://www.webprecisionindia.net

Reply
08/05/2016 12:25am

Too Impressive Substances. I love this article.

Reply
08/06/2016 10:18pm

My Self Nikita From New Delhi Providing Dating Services of Massage in Delhi.

Reply
08/16/2016 3:42am

Hello friends, I am Pari Ahuja and working as independent model escort with Pune escort agency.

Reply
08/16/2016 3:44am

Enjoy high class Pune model escorts services in 3 4 5 star hotels in Pune.

Reply
08/17/2016 3:55am

http://www.sonasharma.in/andheri-east-escorts.html
http://www.suratangel.in/agra-escorts.html
http://www.alinakaur.in/gallery.html

Reply
08/17/2016 3:56am

I'd love to fulfil your fantasies so please don't be shy and tell me what you would like from our time together

Reply
09/04/2016 11:54am

Thanks for sharing blog it’s amazing very nice

Reply
09/17/2016 1:05am

I am Dyna Luis Presently Working As Beirut Escort Girls in Beirut with one of the most reliable and most passionative Beirut Escorts Agecy : Beirut Escort Girls my agency provides you choice of girls without any kind of hasitate and you will fullfill your dream with Beirut Escorts. http://www.beirutescortgirls.com/

Reply
09/17/2016 2:30pm

Thanks For Sharing

Reply
09/25/2016 8:12am

Download zapya for PC free download fully free

Reply



Leave a Reply