Follow the Soapbox
The Guardian
  • City of Cleveland offers 20 lines of defence to family lawsuit
  • Boy, 12, was shot dead by officers while holding a replica gun

The death of Tamir Rice was “directly and proximately” caused by the 12-year-old’s own actions, the city of Cleveland has argued in a defense document following a civil claim from the boy’s family. Rice was shot dead by a police officer last November.

When he was shot, Rice was holding a toy gun that police mistook for a real firearm. The incident sparked widespread criticism that officer Timothy Loehmann, who killed Rice, employed a drastic overuse of force.

The city of Cleveland’s defense, filed with the US district court on Friday, argues that both Rice and members of his family are to blame for any damages, injuries and losses arising from the incident. The argument lists 20 lines of defence, including that Rice did not “exercise due care to avoid injury” and that members of his family, including his mother and teenage sister, who have lodged the claim, sustained damages “caused by their own acts”.

Video footage of the incident outside the Cuddell Recreation Center in Cleveland was obtained by local media under freedom of information laws. It shows Rice’s 14-year-old sister pushed to ground, handcuffed and taken to the back of a patrol car after arriving on the scene and seeing her brother lying in front of her.

Video footage shows Tamir Rice’s sister arriving at the scene of his shooting. The plaintiffs argue in a submission that was revised at the end of January, after the family took on a new legal team, that the 14-year-old screamed “my baby brother, they killed my baby brother” before she was tackled to the ground by officers.

The lawsuit also claims that Loehmann and his partner, Frank Garmback, did not administer first aid to the 12-year-old as he lay bleeding. It was four minutes until another law enforcement official arrived on the scene and administered medical assistance, the submission claims.

The city’s list of 20 defenses does not go into detail. A request for further comment from the Guardian on Sunday was not responded to by deadline.

The 41-page response frequently cites an ongoing police investigation, conducted by the Cuyahoga sheriff’s office in Ohio, as reason for not responding in full. The Cuyahoga sheriff’s office did not respond for a request for comment on the expected date of the investigation’s completion.

The plaintiffs also argue that Loehmann should not have been employed by Cleveland police, after he had been judged unfit for service by another department two years previously.

Cleveland officer who fatally shot Tamir Rice judged unfit for duty in 2012

Loehmann’s personnel file from November 2012, first reported by local media, found the officer “could not follow simple directions, could not communicate clear thoughts nor recollections, and his handgun performance was dismal”.

The city of Cleveland’s response to this argument is that it is “without knowledge or information sufficient” to assess the claims.

Walter Madison, one of the Rice family’s legal team, told NBC news the plaintiffs maintained the 12 year-old was “shot and killed unnecessarily” and that his “death at the hands of an unfit police officer(s) and a division of police that continues to endorse their behavior led to our legitimate lawsuit”.



David Quinly
03/08/2015 1:52pm

I would suggest that the NRA, and their insistence that there be little or no control over firearms, have created an environment where police expect to encounter armed citizens every time they turn around. This does not excuse police use of deadly force in so many of the cases we see, but it should drive them to join the majority against the proliferation of weapons and the efforts by gun profiteers that put so many in danger. There should be serious liability for those behind these policies and the lawmakers who have failed to protect the people.


Good post. It is really help to us. Its give us lots of interest and pleasure. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. Its really a good article. It gives me lots of pleasure and interest..!!

05/16/2016 5:16am

I loved what you've done here. The design is elegant, your content classy. Appreciate this post. I'm interested in your article


Nice and effective blog post. The content is too short but effective. I love the information you share here. Its an well written blog post by you. This is awesome blog post.

05/17/2016 6:08am

I'll be looking forward for more of your posts. Keep it up! I will follow you ..

05/17/2016 6:22am

For me it was very interesting to read this article! thanks for the update..


Thanks for sharing Such A Wonderful Blog With Us..I Like your Post..


Wow! You really impressed me.Thanks for sharing that kind informative post with us.


Best blog to post in this sites like very nice page to post in informative blog commenting this is very useful blog.

05/20/2016 12:57am

I Like that kind a nice Blog. keep's continuous your writing.

05/20/2016 2:14am

Thanks for your facts. You supplied food stuff for believed. Many thanks for sharing the information and facts. All of the most effective to you..!!


Keep Posting the good work ! Really appreciated with this...


Leave a Reply